Although the winner has been revealed, the “American Idol” finale has been marred by a flood of criticism regarding the final vote, which has caused viewers to support a new favourite.

There was a lot of excitement when “American Idol” revealed Jamal Roberts as the season 23 winner on Sunday, May 18, 2025.

Roberts was shown grinning while clutching a winner’s gift basket and his two young girls in a photo posted on the show’s official Facebook page. The post announced the conclusion of this season’s tournament and hailed his win.

Even though Roberts won, his victory sparked intense reactions from the audience, many of whom expressed support for John Foster, the runner-up. The discussion swiftly dominated social media, with several viewers expressing dissatisfaction and disappointment.

On Instagram, several fans shared their thoughts, with one writing, “Eh. John should have won.” Another commented, “John was robbed,” while a third added, “Another rigged season.“

Facebook comments echoed similar sentiments. One person wrote, “John should have won. He was so natural. Jamal screams to [sic] much.”

Another said, “I really think John should have won. We need a good old fashioned country singer. They will all move on, all off them were great [sic].”

Some expressed stronger discontent. A fan shared, “John Foster got robbed. I will not watch next season.” Another quipped, “Yeah, it should have been John Foster cause he’s definitely better [sic].”

An individual echoed a similar concern, “Yep she definitely didn’t like Jamal.” A viewer even appealed for changes, “Jelly Roll pleaseeeeee [sic]she’s got to go!” A disheartened fan didn’t hold back their disappointment, saying, “I hope you don’t be a judge on this show again you bring fake energy. Please don’t come back [sic].”

Viewers were divided by the season’s finale outcomes and guest appearances, which kept the “American Idol” debate going strong despite the season’s spectacular performances and surprising turns.